GEOPOLITICS

The Pattern Trump Can't Break

Osaka, Japan. June 2019. Donald Trump sat across from Xi Jinping at the G20 and folded. He had promised tariffs on $300 billion of Chinese goods. He had vowed to crack down on Huawei. Then he took it all back. China bought some soybeans. Both sides smiled for the cameras. The press called it a truce.

That truce lasted a few months. So did the next one. And the one after that. The same dynamic keeps playing out: Trump threatens, China holds firm, and Trump walks back the threat once the cameras turn on. The question has always been why.

Now we know. A Reuters analysis published Sunday laid it out plainly: Trump has taken a less combative tone ahead of today's summit because of one thing — China's near-total control of rare earth minerals. Not trade deficits. Not soybeans. Not even chips. The 17 metals that go into every F-35 jet engine, every EV motor, and every MRI machine. China refines about 85% of them — down from over 90% a few years ago, but still dominant after six years of "fighting back."

Today Xi Jinping arrives at the White House for his first visit in a decade. It's their second meeting this year, after Trump flew to Beijing in May. The agenda is the same as Busan last October: trade, AI, and critical minerals. But this time the clock is louder. The Busan truce — the deal that paused China's rare earth export controls — expires on November 10. That is 47 days from now.

And even while the truce held, China kept squeezing. Rare earth magnet exports to the U.S. fell 21% in August to 512 tons, according to Chinese customs data reported by Bloomberg. Shipments to Japan dropped 17%. To Germany, 22%. The Diplomat reports that yttrium exports to the U.S. have declined sharply since April 2025, despite China's promise to ease controls. The truce, they wrote, "is quite fragile."

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Vice Premier He Lifeng spent all of Sunday at JPMorgan's Manhattan headquarters trying to close the gaps. Three items on the table: the Busan truce, China's failure to deliver on rare earth commitments from the May summit, and AI rules. The most likely result, analysts say, is a short extension and small gestures — not a real fix. Both sides meet. Both sides talk. Both sides buy time. And China's share stays near 85%.

 
Neodymium
$141.79/kg
▲ +144.5% YTD
 
Praseodymium
$150.69/kg
▲ +151.2% YTD
 
Dysprosium
$239.12/kg
▲ +105.1% YTD
 
Terbium
$1,097/kg
▲ +103.1% YTD
Source: Shanghai Metals Market · Assessed Sep 3, 2026
 
La
 
Ce
 
Pr
 
Nd
 
Sm
 
Eu
 
Gd
 
Tb
 
Dy
 
Ho
 
Er
 
Yb
SPONSORED

America’s answer to universal basic income

Saudi Arabia figured it out.

They pay their citizens $3,600 a month per family. Just for existing. Funded entirely by oil.

Meanwhile, politicians in America are arguing about Twitter, while you get nothing from the $300 billion we generate from oil and gas every year.

But there is a way to collect.

It's called the Patriot Income Plan, or P.I.P. for short.

It's not a government program. It's not a stimulus check. It's not tied to an election or a budget vote.

It's direct ownership in 14 entities that control America's energy infrastructure — pipelines, terminals, processing plants — and pay 10% a year to everyone who holds units.

Put in $10,000 = get $1,000 back.

Put in $50,000 = get $5,000 back.

Put in $100,000 = get $10,000 back.

42 payouts a year. Deposited automatically.

This is universal basic income for people who don't want to wait around for the government to figure it out.

P.I.P. is on pace to pay out $53 billion this year — a record. The next distribution drops in days.

ALSO THIS WEEK

DEFENSE

Aerospace Suppliers Dust Off 1970s Coatings to Replace Rare Earths

Jet engines need thermal barrier coatings to survive extreme heat. For decades, those coatings used yttrium — a rare earth China controls. Now, with yttrium shipments to the U.S. down about 75% in the twelve months through March, suppliers are going back to formulas from the 1970s. Canada's National Research Council and European manufacturer Oerlikon Metco are testing zirconia-based coatings that don't need rare earths at all. Geoffrey Gertz, a former White House national security official, told Reuters: "We are years, not months, away from breaking our dependency on China."

TRADE

Bessent and He Lifeng Spent All Day at JPMorgan Ahead of Today's Summit

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng held an all-day session at JPMorgan Chase's Manhattan headquarters on Sunday. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer joined them. Three items were on the table: the status of the Busan trade truce expiring November 10, China's failure to deliver on rare earth export promises from the May summit, and new AI rules. The U.S. proposed a safety notification system for AI. Neither side reported a deal. The real test comes today at the White House.

EXPORTS

China's Rare Earth Magnet Exports to the U.S. Fell 21% in August

Chinese customs data released this week show rare earth magnet shipments to the U.S. dropped to 512 tons in August — down 21% from July and 13% below the same month last year. Shipments to Japan fell 17% year-over-year. Germany fell 22%. Total Chinese rare earth permanent magnet exports for August hit 5,010 metric tons, down 18% from a year ago, according to Shanghai Metals Market. The numbers land just days before today's summit, where rare earth supply is a top agenda item. Capital Economics noted that Beijing hasn't applied the same squeeze to Europe as it has to the U.S. — but Europe's own dependence leaves it exposed anyway.

SPONSORED

A president used this same move once before in 1934

Trump's approval is at 36%. Midterms are two months away. He needs a move that changes everything overnight.

He has one. It doesn't require Congress. It could add over $1 trillion to the government's balance sheet and potentially make a large number of everyday Americans very wealthy.

A president used this same move once before in 1934. It created generational fortunes. A free report explains what it is and how to get positioned before he plays it.

 
"Even under optimistic scenarios, we are years, not months, away from breaking our dependency on China for rare earths."
— Geoffrey Gertz, former NSC official, senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security · Reuters, September 21, 2026
58
Ce
Cerium
The Most Abundant Rare Earth Nobody Talks About

Cerium is everywhere. It's in the catalytic converter under your car, the polished glass on your phone screen, and the flint in your lighter. It makes up about half of all rare earth ore pulled from the ground — by far the most common of the 17.

This year, while dysprosium and terbium doubled, cerium went the other way — down 5.83% in September, the second straight monthly drop, because supply outpaces demand. That gap shows the two-speed rare earth market: the heavy elements the Pentagon needs are scarce and surging, while the light ones pile up. Even so, China refines most of it. Abundant doesn't mean free.

AROUND THE MARKET

Yttrium Exports to U.S. Still Restricted Despite Busan Truce

China imposed export controls on yttrium and six other rare earths in April 2025. Since then, Beijing has used a "drip-feed" approach to licensing. U.S. imports of yttrium oxide stopped entirely for months, with only small batches resuming. CSIS data show China shipped just 17 tons of yttrium to the U.S. between April and December 2025, compared with 333 tons in the eight months before the controls.

SMM Weekly: NdPr and Terbium Stabilize After Pullback

Shanghai Metals Market's weekly review shows NdPr oxide and terbium oxide prices stopped falling late last week after several days of declines. Dysprosium oxide held flat. Trading volume stayed thin, with buyers waiting for summit results before placing orders.

— Shanghai Metals Market

World Economic Forum Calls Summit a "Managed Stalemate"

The WEF's pre-summit analysis said both sides are "under pressure to extend the pause on major tariff escalation and rare earth export controls." The report noted that the Busan truce created a floor but no lasting structure, and that China wants assurances export controls won't be weaponized further.

Craig Singleton: "China Is Still Using Rare Earths as Leverage"

Craig Singleton, senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, told U.S. News that several May summit commitments remain unfulfilled — including agreements for China to ease access to rare earth minerals and commit billions in agricultural purchases. He described the overall relationship as ongoing competition masked by diplomacy.

Read more from Element 17