PRICES

One Metal, Two Markets

September 7, 2010. A Chinese fishing trawler rammed two Japanese Coast Guard ships near a chain of disputed islands in the East China Sea. The crash was small. What came next was not.

Within weeks, China stopped shipping rare earths to Japan. No formal order. No press release. Ships just sat empty at port.

Japan made nearly all the world's high-end magnets at the time. Without Chinese material, those factories went quiet.

Prices tripled. Governments scrambled. And the world got a lesson it has spent sixteen years trying to unlearn: one country ran the rare earth market, and everyone else was a customer.

China still refines about 90% of the world's rare earths today. But for the first time, the market is splitting in two.

Benchmark Minerals put out its Q3 2026 price review last week. The numbers tell a story the truce headlines missed. Inside China, NdPr oxide barely moved — easing by 1% for the quarter, near $109 per kilogram, though it edged up 1% in September. Outside China, the same stuff rose 12% to about $107 per kilogram. Close. But starting to pull apart.

For heavy rare earths, the split is already dramatic. Benchmark reported that ex-China dysprosium oxide in Europe rose 150% in Q3 alone. Same element. Same grade. Sold on different continents at wildly different prices.

That gap exists because almost no one outside China can refine heavy rare earths at scale. Lynas has shipped split dysprosium. A handful of others say they will, too. But talk is cheap. The premium keeps growing until more plants prove they can run.

Which makes the trade truce feel smaller than it sounds. On September 24, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said the Busan deal would run until January 10, 2027 — two months past its November 10 end date. It keeps tariff pauses and China's rare earth export freezes in place a bit longer.

Markets shrugged. Rare earth stocks fell the next day. USA Rare Earth dropped 1.3%. MP Materials slid. Asian miners pulled back across the board.

Investors had already priced in the deal. What they had not priced in was the Benchmark data showing how little the truce has changed on the ground. The numbers said what the headlines did not.

Chinese rare earth magnet exports to the U.S. fell 13% year-on-year in August to just 512 tons. The export licenses are there on paper. The material is not. And the Pentagon's DFARS ban on Chinese-sourced rare earths in defense still kicks in January 1 — ten days before the new truce end date.

So now there are two rare earth markets. One sits inside China, where prices are flat and supply runs deep. The other sits everywhere else, where heavy rare earths cost two, three, even four times as much and buyers still can't get enough. The truce bought two months. It didn't close the gap.

 
Neodymium
$244.90/kg
▲ 64.03% YTD
 
Praseodymium
$245.40/kg
▲ 70.30% YTD
 
Dysprosium
$930.70/kg
▲ 105.05% YTD
 
Terbium
$4,028.50/kg
▲ 103.11% YTD
Prices as of Sep 11, 2026 · Source: Strategic Metals Invest
 
La
 
Ce
 
Pr
 
Nd
 
Sm
 
Eu
 
Gd
 
Tb
 
Dy
 
Ho
 
Er
 
Yb
SPONSORED

America’s answer to universal basic income

Saudi Arabia figured it out.

They pay their citizens $3,600 a month per family. Just for existing. Funded entirely by oil.

Meanwhile, politicians in America are arguing about Twitter, while you get nothing from the $300 billion we generate from oil and gas every year.

But there is a way to collect.

It's called the Patriot Income Plan, or P.I.P. for short.

It's not a government program. It's not a stimulus check. It's not tied to an election or a budget vote.

It's direct ownership in 14 entities that control America's energy infrastructure — pipelines, terminals, processing plants — and pay 10% a year to everyone who holds units.

Put in $10,000 = get $1,000 back.

Put in $50,000 = get $5,000 back.

Put in $100,000 = get $10,000 back.

42 payouts a year. Deposited automatically.

This is universal basic income for people who don't want to wait around for the government to figure it out.

P.I.P. is on pace to pay out $53 billion this year — a record. The next distribution drops in days.

ALSO THIS WEEK

DATA

Benchmark Puts a Number on the Split

Benchmark Minerals' Q3 2026 rare earth price review shows two markets forming in real time. PrNd oxide held steady inside China at around RMB 729,500 per ton — about $109 per kilogram. Outside China, the CIF price rose 12% to $106,500 per ton. That gap in light rare earths is new but still small. For heavy rare earths, it is not small at all.

Ex-China dysprosium oxide sold to Europe rose 150% from July through September. Terbium moved the same way. Lynas is the only Western firm that has shipped split dysprosium and terbium. Until more plants come online, buyers outside China keep paying more.

POLICY

Europe's Strategic Minerals List Due This Autumn

The EU is expected to name its second round of strategic mineral projects under the Critical Raw Materials Act before year-end. The first round picked 60 projects across the EU and partner countries. Twenty-one of the second-round applications were rare earth projects tied to permanent magnets, and the final list could be bigger.

Brussels has also shortlisted tungsten, rare earths, and gallium for its first joint mineral stockpile, with magnesium under consideration — a direct answer to China's 2025 export controls. The weak spot: Europe mines ore but still sends most of it to other countries for refining. A pile of raw rock does not fix that.

INDUSTRY

Seven Rare Earth Conferences Fill October

October stacks seven major rare earth and critical minerals events across three continents. The lineup includes the 22nd International Rare Earths Conference and the Critical Minerals Expo in Atlanta on October 28–29. That Atlanta show merges for the first time with the Battery Recycling Conference and E-Waste World Conference.

The combo tells you where this business is heading. Rare earth mining, battery metals, and scrap recycling now overlap more than they split apart. Most of these events were small-room affairs a few years ago. Now they draw defense firms, car makers, and government buyers looking for supply they can count on.

SPONSORED

A new type of AI called "Accelerated AI" is about to take the world by storm…

And stocks connected to it are already breaking out: 133%… 210%… and even 320% or more just in the last few months.

But it's just getting started…

If you want to learn more about "Accelerated AI" – and get name and ticker of the #1 pick to play this opportunity…

"To give us more time to see what we can do on the economic front."
— Scott Bessent, U.S. Treasury Secretary, on extending the Busan truce to January 10, 2027, Fox News, September 24, 2026
59
Pr
Praseodymium
140.908
The Element
The Other Half of Every Magnet
Praseodymium never gets top billing. In magnets, it is always paired with neodymium as "NdPr" – the alloy that goes into EV motors, wind turbines, and phone speakers. You rarely hear its name alone, but it makes up about a quarter of the NdPr alloy by weight. It also turns glass yellow-green, which is why it shows up in welder's goggles. At $245.40 per kilogram, praseodymium is up 70% this year and up 237% since 2020, when it traded near $73. Its price moves in lockstep with neodymium because the two come out of the ground together. You can't mine one without the other. Where neodymium goes, praseodymium follows.
AROUND THE MARKET

Asian Rare Earth Stocks Fall on Truce News

Rare earth miners across Asia dropped on September 25, one day after the Busan truce was extended. USA Rare Earth closed down 1.3% at $15.18. MP Materials eased to $48.83. Investors had priced in the two-month deal, and the news set off a broad "sell the truce" move across the sector. Both stocks remain well above their 52-week lows.

Critical Metals Gives Back Gains After Greenland Rally

Critical Metals (CRML) fell 4.2% to $7.83 on September 25 after surging 39% earlier in the week on the U.S.-Denmark-Greenland security pact. The stock still holds an 8.6% gain for the month. The company's Tanbreez project in southern Greenland holds one of the largest known rare earth deposits outside China, with a proposed refinery targeting 19 high-purity rare earth and critical-metal products.

Terbium Premium Over Dysprosium Widens to 4.3×

Terbium metal trades near $4,029 per kilogram on the Shanghai Metals Market as of September — roughly 4.3 times the price of dysprosium per kilogram. The gap keeps growing because terbium is rarer and harder to pull out during refining.

October Stacks Seven Rare Earth Events Across Three Continents

The rare earth conference calendar is packed this month, with seven events across three continents. Highlights include the Critical Minerals Expo in Atlanta (Oct 28–29), combined for the first time with the Battery Recycling Conference and E-Waste World Conference.

Read more from Element 17