In 1995, two Beijing-backed firms bought a company called Magnequench, which ran a rare earth magnet plant in Anderson, Indiana. By the early 2000s, they had packed it all up and shipped it to China. The machines, the recipes, the know-how — all of it.

Anderson lost 200 jobs. America lost the maker of 80 percent of the tiny magnets that guide cruise missiles. No one replaced them.

That was a quarter century ago. Last week, MP Materials shipped its first NdFeB magnets from Fort Worth to GM. The industry cheered. A new chapter, people said.

But Jack Lifton isn't cheering. In a column on InvestorIntel last Wednesday, he argues that America's magnet gap is only half the story. The other half is worse.

Start with the numbers. The U.S. used about 48,000 tonnes of NdFeB magnets in 2025 and made roughly 300. That's 0.6 percent. A gap of 47,700 tonnes.

Those numbers come from Arthur D. Little and were later backed up by Reuters. That's the gap most people talk about. Lifton says there's a second one hiding behind it.

About 29,000 of those 48,000 tonnes didn't arrive as magnets at all. They came built into motors, pumps, cars, robots, and gadgets made abroad. When a car with a magnet in its motor crosses the border, Customs counts a car. The magnet drops out of the data.

So does the plant that built the motor around it. And the copper winding shop. And the steel stamping line. Most of that chain is overseas now.

America doesn't just lack magnets. It lacks the plants that would buy them and turn them into things people use.

You can build a magnet plant in Fort Worth. But if the motor plant that needs those magnets sits in Guangdong, you haven't rebuilt a supply chain. You've built an export dock.

Lifton's fix is to flip the whole model. Don't start at the mine, he says. Start at the product. What does America want to build — an EV motor, a wind turbine, a missile?

Then trace backward through the motor, the magnet, the alloy, the metal, and the ore. Build each link in that order. He calls it "OEM-to-mine" — the reverse of how the U.S. has been thinking about it.

That's how China did it. They didn't just dig up rare earths. They built every plant between the hole in the ground and the finished car. The phrase "mine-to-magnet" sounds complete. It stops in the middle.

The Commerce Department came to the same view in its Section 232 review. A U.S. magnet industry only works if enough of the products that use those magnets are also made here. That word — "if" — is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Right now, with 81 days until the DFARS ban kicks in, nobody has answered it.

Legendary investor Stanley Druckenmiller once said:

“You don't get rich by diversifying into 50 mediocre assets. You get rich by finding two or three asymmetric home runs.”

Jeff Brown just found this NEW asymmetric home run he calls “Elon Musk’s One Stock Retirement Plan.” (Click here for details.)

Shovels hit red dirt 135 km north of Alice Springs last Wednesday. Arafura Rare Earths broke ground on its A$1.6 billion Nolans project — the third ore-to-oxide rare earth mine outside mainland China. Canberra has put in A$1.2 billion and will buy up to 500 tonnes of NdPr oxide per year for its new stockpile.

Gina Rinehart's Hancock holds a big stake, and US Consul General Colin Crosby was at the event — he said he'd brief Washington right away. CEO Darryl Cuzzubbo says the mine will produce NdPr oxide for more than half a century. Binding supply deals are signed with Hyundai, Kia, and Siemens Gamesa, along with a non-binding MoU with GE. It took two decades to get this far. Now they have three years to build it.

Terbium oxide jumped 41 percent in one week outside China. Fastmarkets now puts it at $5,000–$8,000 per kg. Dysprosium oxide rose to $2,500–$3,500 per kg. The cause: the Pentagon's January 2027 ban on Chinese-origin magnets is 81 days away.

U.S. buyers are paying far more than European ones for the same stuff. Inside China, dysprosium still trades at a fraction of those prices. The gap is roughly ten to one, and it keeps widening.

India wants to build its own rare earth supply chain from the ground up. Joint Secretary of Mines Kadam Sandeep Vasant said so at the India Mines and Minerals Conclave on October 9. The country has big rare earth deposits but has relied on one state-run firm, IREL, for refining for decades without scaling up.

Now the National Critical Mineral Mission is paying for R&D to move refining tech from lab tests to real plants. The plan also covers urban mining and pulling metals from old mine waste. For metals India lacks — like lithium — the goal includes buying from other countries. India holds about 6 percent of the world's rare earth reserves but still refines almost none of them at scale.

Take a look at this…

It's a radical "light-speed" device that's turning AI as we know it into "Accelerated AI", making it 100 times faster and 100 times more energy efficient.

In fact, Jensen Huang, Nvidia's founder and CEO, says this device is shattering the limitations of AI and without it, AI can't scale.

If you want to discover what this technology is, why Nvidia is betting billions on it…

And the one stock we believe could be the biggest winner when "Accelerated AI" goes mainstream…

Click here to see all the details.

Christopher Ecclestone of Hallgarten & Company told InvestorIntel the market is getting picky. Some shortages are real and will last for years. Others are short-term spikes from trade curbs that could fade before new mines ever produce. He pointed to antimony's price drop as an early warning and said tungsten has a stronger long-term case.

— InvestorIntel · October 7, 2026

Defense Metals released drill results from ten holes at its Wicheeda rare earth project in B.C. The best hit: 2.33 percent total rare earth oxide over 153 meters. Western pit wall holes exceeded the current model, though southern pit area holes came in below predicted grades. A resource upgrade is next.

— PRNewswire · October 8, 2026

Statistics Canada says critical mineral output added C$26.3 billion to the economy last year — about 0.9 percent of GDP and a third of all mining. The sector backed 57,500 jobs. Canada raised C$10.4 billion in mining equity last year, too. Numbers like that give Ottawa a strong reason to keep spending.

— Statistics Canada / The Hub · October 8, 2026

USA Rare Earth fell 4.5 percent to $12.63 on October 8. US Antimony dropped 3.6 percent. MP Materials dipped less than 1 percent. The selling hit firms still building out their plants hardest, while the one proven producer held up. No single news event drove the move — it looked like broad risk-off selling across the sector.

— 24/7 Wall St. · October 8, 2026