ANALYSIS
Billions In, but Where Are the Magnets?
In the summer of 2006, a group of Chinese rare earth companies did something nobody else wanted to do. They spent years building separation plants in provinces most Western investors couldn't find on a map. They hired metallurgists. They ran pilot lines that failed. They ran them again. By the time anyone in Washington noticed, China could turn raw ore into a finished magnet faster and cheaper than any country on earth.
Twenty years later, the United States is trying to reverse that in five. Since June, Washington has committed close to $2.9 billion in direct federal funding to rebuild a rare earth magnet supply chain outside China. USA Rare Earth broke ground last week on a $1.2 billion, 800,000-square-foot magnet plant in Blacksburg, South Carolina, designed to produce 6,400 metric tons of sintered NdFeB magnets a year. Energy Fuels agreed to buy German magnet maker Vacuumschmelze for $1.9 billion. The DOE just handed $500 million to seven new projects.
That's a lot of money. Jack Lifton thinks the money is the problem.
In a piece published last week on InvestorNews, the Critical Minerals Institute co-chair argued that America's supply chain effort rests on a dangerous assumption: that once enough money has been raised, the factories will follow. They won't, he says. A financing closes on one day. Building the people, the process knowledge, and the equipment to run a continuous separation line takes years. The IEA's 2026 outlook backs him up. Outside China, planned refining covers roughly two-thirds of expected mined supply by 2035, but planned magnet production covers only one-third. The middle of the chain is still missing.
And then the market reminded everyone what uncertainty looks like. On Thursday, rare earth stocks sold off hard. USAR fell 4%. MP Materials dropped 5%. REMX sank 5% against a flat S&P. The reason? Hopes that the September 24 Xi-Trump summit might produce a deal — which would ease China's export controls and pull the floor out from under the scarcity trade that sent these stocks flying all year.
That's the paradox. Billions are going in. Plants are being built. But the sector's market value still depends more on what Beijing decides in November than on what Washington funds in September. Lifton put it plainly: a higher valuation does not demonstrate a higher recovery rate. A successful financing does not demonstrate reliable production. Until a finished magnet reaches an American factory floor, the supply chain exists only on paper.
|
| Source: Strategic Metals Invest · Ex-China retail reference |
|
SPONSORED
A new type of AI called "Accelerated AI" is about to take the world by storm…
And stocks connected to it are already breaking out: 133%… 210%… and even 320% or more just in the last few months.
But it's just getting started…
If you want to learn more about "Accelerated AI" – and get name and ticker of the #1 pick to play this opportunity…
ALSO THIS WEEK
MANUFACTURING
USA Rare Earth Breaks Ground on Its Biggest Plant Yet
USA Rare Earth broke ground September 9 on an 800,000-square-foot factory in Blacksburg, South Carolina. The $1.2 billion plant will produce 6,400 metric tons of sintered NdFeB magnets and 5,000 metric tons of strip-cast metal per year, with commissioning set for 2028. Combined with its Stillwater, Oklahoma operation, USAR expects 10,000 metric tons of domestic magnet capacity. The company also completed its merger with Serra Verde on September 3, adding the only non-Asian mine that supplies all four magnetic rare earths at scale.
MARKETS
Rare Earth Stocks Sell Off on Summit Hopes
Rare earth equities tumbled Thursday after reports that the September 24 Xi-Trump summit could produce a deal extending China's export control pause. USAR dropped 4%. MP Materials fell 5%. The VanEck REMX ETF sank 5% against a flat S&P 500. The move shows how much of the sector's value rests on the scarcity premium. MP posted Q2 revenue of $108.5 million, up 89% year over year, but that wasn't enough to hold shares when the diplomatic headline hit.
TRADE
Zero Dysprosium or Terbium Oxide Has Reached Japan This Year
Fastmarkets reported that no dysprosium oxide or terbium oxide has been exported from China to Japan in all of 2026, according to Chinese customs data. Japan is the largest consumer of both metals outside China. Beijing has kept sending finished NdFeB magnets — the high-value product — while choking off the raw materials Japan needs to make its own. The pattern holds even though China approved some export licenses. The G7 responded in June by pledging to cut reliance on any single rare earth supplier to below 60% by 2030.
SPONSORED
Elon Musk's New Invention Will Blow You Away
Elon Musk did it again! After self-driving cars…
Reusable rockets that land themselves…
And brain chips that let paralyzed people control computers with their minds…
A new form of AI so powerful he called it an "infinite money glitch."
And it could help send shares of this little-known Elon Musk supplier to the moon.
|
|
AROUND THE MARKET
CMR Podcast: Xi Comes to Washington with Minerals on the Line
The latest Critical Minerals Report Podcast covered Chinese suppliers who stopped shipping rare earths to American buyers even after getting valid export licenses. No evidence ties the refusals to a Beijing order, but the effect is the same: regulatory approval does not mean delivery. The Xi-Trump summit on September 24 is now the clearest chance to address the problem before the November 10 export control deadline.
DOE Awards $500 Million to Seven Critical Mineral Projects
The Department of Energy's Office of Critical Minerals and Energy Innovation selected seven projects for its third round of battery materials grants. Lilac Solutions, Jervois, and Nth Cycle each received $100 million for lithium extraction, cobalt refining, and battery recycling. Four smaller projects split the remaining $200 million.
Artemis II Commander to Keynote Adamas Rare Earth Conference
NASA astronaut Reid Wiseman, who commanded the Artemis II lunar flyby, will open Adamas Intelligence's Rare Earth Mines, Magnets & Motors 2026 on September 28–30 in Toronto. The three-day conference brings together industry leaders, magnet makers, and defense buyers ahead of the November 10 deadline.
T.I.C. 67th General Assembly Opens in Yinchuan
The Tantalum-Niobium International Study Center began its annual conference September 13 at the JW Marriott in Yinchuan, China. Tantalum and niobium are not rare earths, but they move through the same trading houses and often share ore bodies. The T.I.C. represents about 80 member companies from 30 countries.


